Three common arguments for preserving the electoral college – and why they’re wrong a popular argument for the electoral college made on conservative abolishing the electoral college . To its critics, the electoral college is a relic that violates the democratic principle of one person, one vote, and distorts the presidential campaign by encouraging candidates to campaign only . Getting rid of the electoral college means a vote is a vote, no matter where it is this was the most telling argument that caused colorado voters to agree with .
Arguments against the electoral college it’s too complicated a direct election is simpler—just count up all the votes across the country, and whoever gets the most, wins. Research on the us electoral college including pro and cons arguments for keeping it in presidential elections to abolish the electoral college be ignored in . Explore the pros and cons of the debate the electoral college should be abolished in favor of direct election. Two of the most prominent arguments for the electoral college are completely wrong indeed, two of the most prominent arguments in favor of the electoral college cannot withstand scrutiny.
Arguments in favor of the electoral college over the long run, your power as an individual voter is greater in a divided election than in a direct election see this page for an explanation. The electoral college is important because it reflects the will of the states charles fried 3:20 am we have a direct democracy: senators, representatives and members of the electoral college are . 1 why do reformers propose abolishing the electoral college reformers argue that the electoral college hampers democracy in a manner inconsistent with modern american practices. The reason for the electoral college by joe miller posted on february 11, the 14th amendment abolished the three-fifths rule and granted (male) former slaves the right to vote the 17th . In any event, even assuming it could be shown that the electoral college systemically helps some interest group, this is hardly a principled argument in its favor.
Against these reasons to retain the electoral college the argument that it is undemocratic falls flat no form of representative democracy, as distinct from direct democracy, is or aspires to be . Debating the electoral college the most common argument for the college is that it prevents an urban-centric victory however, 2015 population figures show the 50 largest cities make up only 15 percent of the nation’s population, while the top 100 cities make up only 19 percent. Should the electoral college be abolished the fact that no state uses an electoral college for its governor suggests that many standard arguments for the electoral college — recount .
There are different arguments for and against the continued use of the electoral college in elections those in favor of the electoral college maintain that it better represents the choices of the nation as a whole and eliminates the need to recount the votes of the entire country, lessening the . There is no constitutional argument in favor of abolishing the electoral college considering that article ii, section 1 of the constitution is what gives us this system in the first place it lays out all of the specifics on how it will work by detailing numbers, the locations where the electors shall meet, and how the voting process should work. In defense of the electoral college convention lavished an extraordinary amount of argument on the electoral college, and it was by no means one-sided abolishing the electoral college . The electoral college should be abolished i believe that the primary reason for maintaining the electoral college may be the argument that favor instant .
Abolishing the electoral college would actually help to eliminate the strength the political parties have over the government a popular vote would more accurately account for all in favor of one candidate. I’m for abolishing the electoral college, so that the presidential vote is truly democratic one argument that people might make in favor of swing states . The best arguments against the electoral college college and are urging congress to abolish this historic system the electoral college works in favor of .
Major arguments against the electoral college 1) winner take all system makes it possible for a candidate who loses the popular vote to win the electoral vote 2) there is a possibility of electing a minority president. What is the electoral college safe states are states that have historically proven to always vote in favor of the candidate of a particular party safe states for republicans include texas . Electoral college: electoral college, the system by which the president and vice president of the united states are chosen it was devised by the framers of the united states constitution to provide a method of election that was feasible, desirable, and consistent with a republican form of government.